In the 170-year history of Iranian journalism, never before have journalists and publishers been facing as much pressure and oppression as they are now.
A while ago a friend of mine, who is a publisher in Tehran, said that although he has always faced problems under the Islamic Republic, there never was a time when he experienced all the problems at the same time. There have always been levers of power in Iran's state-owned institutions which the state has used to implement its macro- and micro-level policies with respect to the press, journalists and publishers. These illegal levers of power allow state officials in Iran to aid their supporters and affiliates and to limit others, if necessary even drive them into bankruptcy and out of competition.
State officials are able to do this through, for example, granting financial grants or expensive advertisements or cheap paper quotas to affiliated newspapers and publishers and refusing to issue permits for critical newspapers and publishers, or worse yet, direct and indirect censorship of the press and books and dozens of other announced and unannounced measures. These measures are like mighty weapons in the hands of Ministry of Culture officials to aid whomever that they wish and stifle whomever that they do not approve of, for one reason or another.
The aforementioned levers have been used periodically in accordance with conditions and opportunities and policies of the culture minister or the group in charge of the ministry. In some eras (as during Khatami's time) state pressure was decreased and in other eras pressure was increased. In the past three years, however, all levers of pressure have been fully utilized against critical media outlets, publishers and artists. Currently the road for free travel of information and publication of ideas is fully closed by organs such as the Ministry of Culture. Not even the situation in the 1980s and during the Iran-Iraq war rivaled today's.
Another aspect of peculiarity of the present situation is that, in using the present levers, the government and Ministry of Culture and security organizations are trying not to leave the smallest opening for presence of critical voices, which can protest and take their complaint, through legal channels, to legal institutions inside the country or at least legitimate and respected international institutions. The judiciary, far from processing complaints against illegal actions of the Ministry of culture and other state institutions perpetrated against critical media outlets, actually openly engages in suppressing journalists and intellectuals.
If in the past, and especially during the Khatami administration, publications were shut don by the judiciary, or journalists were arrested, or a book was suspended or censored, there would have been widespread and somewhat effective protests by society and in the press and Majlis and administration, and at least the autocrats were forced to pay a price.
Presently, however, the administration's illegal actions are not provable (for instance, critical publications are not given publication permits so that they do not have to be shut down later), complaints are not processed, there is no capacity for widespread protest, and no one among the public and especially in the world really knows what is going on in Iran.
The bitter truth is that the writers, journalists and artists of this land are slowly and silently silenced and destroyed. Very recently, a weekly like "Shahrvan-e Emrooz," which was published through the determination of the remainder of the generation of reformists journalists, and was an honorable phenomenon in Iran's press family, was banned in an illegal manner. The same took place with respect to "Shargh" and "Ham-Mihan" in the not very distant past. Who is left to protest and which protest is attended to? Ho many people are left who can understand the depth of pain and even suppressed rage of journalists who suddenly are unemployed and exposed to government pressure?
Finally, though it has a been a while since the conclusion of the golden years of Iranian journalism (1997 to 2000), and only a handful of semi-independent and critical publications are left which are able to remain active by respecting all the established legal and illegal red lines and in very difficult conditions, even this much seems to be intolerable for the government. The government's level of intolerance in face of criticism is so high that another wave of confrontation (with the handful of remaining publications) seems inevitable. The difference is that, this time, not even conservative publications that criticize the administration from time to time will be spared the purge.





