Unsatisfactory Conditions and Imam Mahdi
More Responses to Ahmadinejad’s New Remarks - 2008.05.19
Arash Motamed
Last week President Ahmadinejad once again alluded to the relations between his administration and Imam Mahdi who is believed by Shiites to be in occultation. He said, “The real manager of the government is in reality Imam Mahdi and not the president. … The hand of the Imam guides and manages the government.”
These remarks brought about responses from groups across the Iranian political spectrum. Not only reformists, but even some prominent personalities in the conservatist camp (to which the President himself belongs to) criticized Ahmadinejad for his words. A senior Majlis representative from the majority faction and the spokesperson for the powerful Jame Rohaniyate Mobarez (Association of the Militant Clergy) group which is an influential organization within the conservative camp Gholamreza Mesbahchi Moghadam pointed to the disorderly economic conditions of Iran and said, “If by these remarks the president means that Imam Mahdi supports the behavior of this administration, then one must say that this is completely wrong. The Imam certainly does not approve of a 20 percent inflation rate and so does not support it, as he would not many other issues, including mistakes and mismanaged conditions that exist around the country.”
Another Majlis deputy Madani Bejestani said this in response to Ahmadinejad’s claims, “We do not deny that the holy Imams are monitoring everything and do not reject the existence of hidden divine assistance in support of the revolution. But by attributing everything in the country to the Imams we are also attributing the mistakes that our officials in the Majlis, government and judiciary may make to the divinity. So we must be very careful in not damaging the divine institution.” Yet another Majlis deputy, Ali Asghari from Mashhad also criticized Ahmadinejad in these words, “We are aware that Mr. Ahmadinejad is associating his management of the country to that of the Imam Mahdi. But in reality is this how the Imam would have managed the affairs? It would be better for Mr. Ahmadinejad to remain accountable for the issues in society, such as inflation and rising costs.”
Mehdi Karubi, the former Majlis speaker and current secretary general of reformist Etemad Melli party, who remains a potential rival to Mr. Ahmadinejad in next year’s presidential race, also reacted to the president’s claims regarding Imam Mahdi. While stressing that “we must not associate the current unfavorable conditions in the country to Imam Mahdi,” said, “Is it Imam Mahdi’s rule that has resulted in the doubling of housing prices since last year or the suffering that people face because of inflation and rising prices?” Referencing Ahmadinejad’s remarks at Columbia University in New York when he made similar claims, Karubi said, “I must admit that a number of Iranian diplomats told me while expressing their disappointment at these remarks that the words in reality tarnished our image. And still, Mr. Ahmadinejad insists that Imam Mahdi was running the events at the time.”
But perhaps the most interesting response to the president’s remarks came from none other than Mahdavi Kani, also a former Majlis speaker and current secretary general of the powerful Jamiyate Rohaniyate Mobarez (a radical clerical grouping). According to Tabnak news website in his ethics class at Imam Sadegh University, Kani said this in response to a question by a student: “Mr. Ahmadinejad should not be saying such things because it creates a negative impression of Imam Mahdi in the eyes of the public.” According to Tabnak’s reporter Kani then asked this question: “If it was Imam Mahdi who was running the show, then does this mean that he cannot get rid of the mafia? Is the 5,000 Toman price for rice also his doing?” He concluded his reference by saying that “With all his greatness, Imam Khomeini never made such remarks about Imam Mahdi.”
