From National Security to Psychological Security
Asie Amini - 2008.02.17

After a record of 22 years in the publishing world, Zanan monthly magazine was shut down by the revocation of its publishing permit for “publishing news and articles in a manner that resulted in the denial of psychological security of society, for endangering the spiritual, mental and psychological of its readers, for the portrayal that there was no security in society and for downgrading the condition of women in the Islamic Republic of Iran,” as quoted by insiders of the Tehran government.
Let us review the issues of Zanan over the past twelve months, and look at its story titles, reports, articles, and the issues that made its cover photos.
Of the twelve published issues, the titles of the key reports belonged to two special issues that came out (Iranian New Year and International Women’s Day). Amongst the remaining releases, the covers of seven issues portrayed the message that its readers would not be always confronting the darkest and bitterest images in life and thus displayed colorful and in contrast to some of the bitter issues of the day. The main report of the social section of the magazine in nine of its issues, called the “dossier of the month”, was an investigative report which had to be published on professional grounds. How can one expect the journalists and reporters of Zanan to avoid writing about the most important current issues of Iranian women in the country? The issues included the bill for the protection of families, advocating temporary marriages, polygamy, limitations on women applying to universities, stoning, and the events following the March 8 and Khordad 22 (a peaceful women’s march last year) incidents. If such reporting is fake, then what are the real issues of the day? And if analyzing and debating current issues leads to social disruption, who is shall be held responsible for it: those who investigate the issues and strive to show their causes, or those officials who are charged with preventing them and other social ills?
Iranian journalists and writers and civic activists have in recent years come to learn of the labels that thrown at them, such as political crimes, acts against national security, disrupting public order, etc. These were the results of writings that carried political semblance. With Zanan’s ban, writers must now be aware that even writing about social issues can lead to charges such as engaging in acts against national security, or against the psychological security of the public.
There is no doubt that some of the titles of the articles published by Zanan last year were not the happiest ones, but what is one supposed to do when such unhappy events actually exist and take place in the country? I ask this question as a journalist whose training and thoughts have now been completely dislodged because of this strange state of events. SO my question is that whether we as journalists have to ignore the negative events that go on in our society? Must we then write fiction and lies? Must I ignore anything that can shake me and jolt my life?
Our universities are in the hands of the authorities. Change the press laws so that critique and analysis are no longer the virtues in the work of writers and journalists. We have not heard any ideology preach that a journalist should turn his back to the issues around him.
And so Zanan magazine is shut as well. But what are you going to do with what we have learned from Zanan, and through experience?
