A Confession to Failure
The President’s First Economic Report to the Public - 2007.12.19

Hamid Ahadi
For the first time, President Mahmud Ahmadinejad publicly acknowledged inflation, depreciation of the value of the Rial and price hikes. But even while acknowledging the failure of his administration’s policies, he did not take responsibility for the worsening economic conditions. Still, he made new promises of improving the economy by reducing inflation and raising the value of foreign currencies.
Economists pounced on the report, which came on the President’s fourth pilgrimage to Saudi Arabia, saying it was full of contradictions and inconsistencies. Many of the same economists had warned the government about some of the ills that are not being reported in the government account.
One of the key issues in the report is the government’s acknowledgment of the relationship between liquidity and inflation, which these very same officials vehemently denied 2 years ago, calling the relationship foreign imported theories.
It appears that the necessity to acknowledge the ills and issues permeating the Iranian economy came about by Iran’s Central bank after the survival of the new governor of the Central Bank following intense pressures to resign. While Ahmadinejad presented statistics to support the degree of inflation, liquidity and other indicators – which were miles apart from what he had promised - he stopped short conceding that his administration’s policies were responsible for the trends. The report mentioned that banks were responsible for some of the ills, without making it clear that all banks in Iran operate under the full supervision and control of the government and its agencies. The president took credit for the increase in petro-dollars as income, but said that inflation and unpredicted costs of imported petroleum and refined products were the cause of inflation that was rampant in the Iranian economy.
In previous year, the tone of similar economic reports always blamed the opposition for economic ills such as inflation. This time however it calls inflation to be a basic and fundamental issue.
This year’s report also translated economic indicators and indices into more popular language. Contrary to this year’s report, previous accounts denied the role of foreign sources on the national economy, or challenged the view that some of the problems had arisen because of poor government planning. In one instance when Majlis deputies questioned some of the figures mentioned in the report, the President mocked the representatives by inviting them to buy their fruit from the stores in his neighborhood. One of the President’s advisors disclosed later that a few weeks after that incident, each of the presidential advisors brought a paper bag full of fruit and placed it on the cabinet table to disprove the “claims” of the Majlis deputies and the media that criticized the government’s economic report.
At that time the President even called those who questioned the statistics in the government’s economic report and presented a grimmer, albeit more realistic picture of the economic indicators, traitors that needed to be investigated. While presenting his report the President did request that the public forgive him for the mistakes and shortcomings that emanated from him.
